False Arrest: Busted for Bad Words
New York State Court of Claims: DePaula v. State
Like they say on TV, don’t try this at home if you’re not a professional.
Claimant is an attorney. He was a little late for Civil Court in Queens, having missed the first call of the calendar. Like many of us, he had a few cases on in court that morning. While sitting in the back of the crowded courtroom as the judge conferenced cases at the bench, his cell phone rang. Unfortunately, it was not set on vibrate. After less than a half minute of talk, he was approached by a court officer.
Rather than admonish Mr. DePaula, the officer confiscated his phone. As irritating as that may have been, he also advised the busy barrister that he could “get the phone back at about 1:00 PM” when court was in recess. Apparently, they really take the turn-off-your-cell-phone rules seriously in Civil Queens.
There is some discrepancy about what happened next: Attorney DePaula says that while he waited for his case to be called, the officer walked toward him. The officer claims that after he took the phone and was attending to his courtroom duties, DePaula was “staring at him” before he walked over. Both sides agree that when the officer approached, he told DePaula “you should know better.” In response, the attorney admits saying, “You’re just being a prick ” (by which he meant to convey that the officer was a “contemptible, disagreeable, obnoxious person”), while the officer claimed Depaula said, “in a loud nasty tone: ‘You know something, you’re a prick’” (which he treated as a “disruption” of the court proceedings taking place), whereupon DePaula was asked, but refused, to leave the courtroom. Both do agree, however, that DePaula was immediately arrested, handcuffed, removed from the courtroom and confined in a security office in the courthouse, giving new meaning to the term call waiting.
After fifteen or twenty minutes handcuffed incommunicado in the cooler, the officer returned. The cuffs were removed, the cell phone returned and a summons for disorderly conduct was issued. DePaula pleaded not guilty, went to trial on the discon charge, and was acquitted. He then sued in the Court of Claims for False Arrest and Malicious Prosecution.
According to the Court of Claims, “the elements of a false arrest cause of action are: (1) the defendant intended to confine claimant; (2) claimant was conscious of the confinement; (3) claimant did not consent to the confinement; and (4) the confinement was not otherwise privileged.” When there’s an arrest without warrant, the burden shifts to the defendant to “establish that the arrest was privileged,” thus validating a charge of disorderly conduct under Penal Law §240.20 (3). As it turns out, the court officer had a wrong number, and the arrest was held not to be privileged.
As the court politely put it, “however reprehensible the utterance Mr. DePaula chose to make, in a courtroom and addressed to a Court Officer, the statement alone did not, as a matter of law, amount to disorderly conduct. The law is well settled that the mere use of 'abusive or obscene language' in a public place does not constitute a violation of Penal law §240.20 (3),” as the Court of Appeals has already held. As for the claim of malicious prosecution, the court did not find the requisite “actual malice” and so dismissed that count. A hearing on damages was scheduled to follow.
It’s reassuring to know that the breakdown of civility in our society has transcended the streets, giving us all the right to speak our mind to whomever we want wherever we are, even within the hallowed halls of justice. That’s probably a good thing legally (and maybe it’s an inroad of sorts into the constraints of political correctness), but culturally it may leave something to be desired.
Still, if you’re going to speak your mind, be prepared to put in the time. Your rights often come at a cost. And sometimes, especially when it involves going to court, the cost is billed by the hour. Which is why such bold speech is probably best left to the professionals.
Just ask Mr. DePaula. But ask him nicely.
